This is my Grandma’s recipe.
And I just love that my Grandma loves Oreo crusts as much as I do.
This is Oreo crust and ice cream dreamland. It can’t not be addicting when it starts with a seriously thick layer of crushed Oreos with melted butter pressed into a pan, and is then topped with a borderline inappropriately rich layer of homemade fudge sauce, and finally covered with soft ice cream which should definitely be Peanut Butter Panic. Juuuust so you know. When you freeze all of that together, something amazing happens and it’s going to make you the most popular person this fourth of July.
Okay, so maybe it’s a little eleventh hour of me to be posting a recipe that could be for the fourth of July just 15 hours before the actual fourth of July. But I’ve always been a little eleventh hour when it comes to holiday specific foods. And besides, isn’t this just anytime summer food? Edit: anytime food?
I actually really like ice cream, even in the winter. In Minnesota. I live on the edge, you guys. I’m sure it has nothing to do with the fact that we keep our house ridiculously, expensively, embarrassingly warm all through the winter so that Bjork doesn’t have to hear me complaining about how cold my toes are and deal with me leaving the oven open from November to April. Ice cream is just that kinda food.
I have a few tips for success as you start to create this Oreo ice cream wonderland in the next 20 seconds.
First, don’t use too much ice cream. Otherwise you’ll take it to a dinner party and proudly unveil the dessert you brought to share with 4 couples and realize that no, a 3 foot thick layer of ice cream will not, in fact, freeze all the way through. And then you’ll serve something called Oreo fudge ice cream soup instead. And if you have a food blog? You might feel kind of bad about that. Even though it actually still tastes kind of good because it’s ice cream and crushed Oreos and fudge.
Another thing: Pour the fudge right on the crust. The first time I made this I poured the fudge over the ice cream and sort of swirled it in and had a bit of a disaster. Plus I missed out on the epic thickness of that double punch Oreo-fudge crust layer. It’s not to be messed with, you guys. The takeaway is that a molten hot chocolate sauce poured over something frozen will be, uh, annoying. Keep it in order and go for the fudge-topped crust instead.
Which leads me to the next thing. Don’t over-soften the ice cream. It’s totally tempting to just zap it in the microwave for like, what, 8 minutes? I know because I gave in during round one of this ice cream madness and ended up basically pouring ice cream milk over the top layer. The biggest problem here is that it won’t refreeze in the same way and you’ll be cursing at your microwave instead of enjoying the soft creamy texture of the refrozen, appropriately softened ice cream. So just take it slow. Be okay with more firm, more messy ice cream assembly. It should be more like PRESSED over the crust.
Final thing to know is that the ice cream variety is up to you, but I would like to strongly suggest Peanut Butter Panic, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, Bunny Tracks, Moose Tracks, cookies and cream, or any other type of ice cream that is full of chocolate chunks and caramel swirls and stuff like that. My Grandma uses Moose Tracks and everyone dies every time. IT’S SO GOOD.
PS. Moose Tracks? Is that a Minnesota thing?
- 1 lb. (1 package) Double Stuf Oreo cookies
- 15 tablespoons butter
- ¾ cup semisweet chocolate chips
- 1½ cups (1 tall can) evaporated milk
- 2 cups powdered sugar
- ½ gallon ice cream: choose a flavor you like to make it interesting! Swirled with caramel, stuffed with peanut butter cups, etc.
- For the crust: Crush the Oreos in a food processor until fine and crumbly. Melt 7 tablespoons of butter. Add the melted butter to the crushed Oreos and stir to combine. Press the mixture into a 9x13 pan. Place the pan in the refrigerator or freezer to set the crust.
- For the fudge sauce: Take the ice cream out of the freezer so it starts to soften. (I do NOT recommend over softening the ice cream in the microwave because in my experience, it did not refreeze as well.) In a medium saucepan, melt 8 tablespoons butter, chocolate chips, evaporated milk, and powdered sugar. Stir continuously until the mixture boils. Let the mixture boil for 8 minutes, stirring continuously. Remove from heat and let cool slightly.
- Assembling: Pour the fudge sauce over the crust. Allow to rest for a few minutes so the fudge sauce continues to cool. Scoop the softened ice cream over the crust and spread or press gently to create an even top layer. It's a little messy - that's ok. It doesn't have to be perfectly smooth. Freeze again for a few hours or until solid. When you're ready to serve, let the pan sit out for 10 minutes so it softens. This makes it easier to cut and eat.
- - eCookbook with our top 25 recipes
- - Email Updates for new recipes
- - Exclusive discounts on our products