Homemade Poppy Seed Dressing

Homemade Poppy Seed Dressing

I’m going salad crazy.

After living in the Philippines for a year, where it’s easy to forget about things like fresh spinach and arugula, where salads are usually the culprit for any and all stomach sickness, and where the Chopped Thai Chicken Salad happened out of pure necessity (okayyy that was a definite exception), I am welcoming Salad back into my life with open arms.

Now that we’re home, I’ve been treated to a few REALLY good salads: a restaurant BBQ Chopped Chicken Salad, a Chipotle burrito bol “salad”, and my Mom’s cabbage-almond slaw salad. And then naturally, there have been a few forgettable ones that usually compliment a meal like frozen pizza. I think you know the kind.

Homemade Poppy Seed Dressing

But the salad that I’ve been eating lately? It’s the ultimate winner. It has Summer 2013 written all over it, and no I would not be sad if I had to eat it every day until September. Yes, I’m still talking about salad, the green thing with healthy stuff.

It’s filled with fruit, protein, greens, nuts, plus it’s totally gorgeous, aaaand it’s smothered in homemade poppy seed dressing. It’s a Chicken and Nectarine Poppy Seed Salad, so in preparation for that rainbow of glory, I’m giving you the poppy seed dressing recipe today. Like how I planned ahead on that one? Mmhm.

What I like about it:

  1. It’s easy.
  2. It uses simple ingredients.
  3. It’s lower in calories and fat than the store bought stuff.
  4. It is spoon-lickably good.
  5. Bam.

Homemade Poppy Seed Dressing

4.8 from 4 reviews
Homemade Poppy Seed Dressing
Serves: 6
  • 2 tablespoons chopped shallot
  • ½ tablespoon butter
  • 3 tablespoons Greek vanilla or plain yogurt
  • ¼ cup olive oil mayonnaise
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • 1 tablespoon semi-sweet white wine (optional)
  • ½ tablespoon cider vinegar
  • 2 teaspoons sugar
  • ½ tablespoon water
  • 2-3 tablespoons poppy seeds
  1. Saute the shallot in the butter over medium low heat for 5-10 minutes or until the shallot is very soft and fragrant.
  2. In a food processor, place the yogurt, mayonnaise, olive oil, wine, vinegar, sugar, and the sauteed shallots. Puree until smooth. Taste and adjust as necessary. Add the water to adjust the consistency if it needs to be thinned. Stir in the poppy seeds and just like that, you're good to go! Don't forget to keep it refrigerated.
Makes about 1 cup of dressing. Nutrition information is for one serving (about 3 tablespoons).


Subscribe for these valuable resources:
  • eCookbook with our top 25 recipes
  • Email Updates for new recipes
  • Exclusive discounts on our products



  1. I’m so happy you are able to enjoy salads again!! I’ve been obsessed with poppyseed dressing lately since I started picking up this superfood kale salad mix at Costco the last few times, not enough dressing included in my opinion :)
    Can’t wait to make your homemade recipe!

    • Janet lee says:

      Thats EXACTLY what I need it for!!!! The kale salad from costco is great, but not nearly enough dressing!! I’ve tried other favors of dressing on it, but the poppyseed is the perfect match!

  2. I love poppy seed dressing! So excited to see an easy homemade version. I’m going to pin in so I remember it when I plan out my meal’s for next week.

  3. I totally need to start making my own salad dressing! Why have I not done this? Shame.

  4. Yay for salads! This dressing sounds awesome!

  5. Time to bust out the cute homemade dressing jar with the measures right on it that we got as a wedding gift. Yay for poppyseeds. They are just so little and fun. Can’t wait for tomorrow’s big reveal!

  6. That salad is beautiful! Can’t wait for the recipe! (oh and poppyseed dressing + peaches = AMAZING)

  7. I love poppyseed anything. I need to make this dressing asap!

  8. That salad looks SO pretty!

  9. I love poppy seed dressing, so thank you for a homemade version!

  10. I’ve totally forgotten about poppy seed dressing! YUMMMMM

  11. Salads really are the best, aren’t they? I’ve been experimenting with different vinaigrettes lately, but no poppy seeds dressing yet. This is definitely going on the list of things to try!

  12. anna marie says:

    no way! i was just thinking TODAY that i should make poppyseed chicken. i’m vegeterian actually but taking dinner to a friend and thought that sounded good. i love your blog and have tried TONS of your recipes! keep up the great work!

  13. Oh. My. Yum….

  14. Love poppy seed dressing. Usually I buy Marie’s. :) I am going to give this a whirl. Thanks!

  15. Just yesterday, I was searching for THIS salad. Seriously. The one that screams Summer 2013! I will be back to find what the actual salad recipe is, but for now is so excited for at least the dressing. LOVE the natural ingredients blended into something that looks so beautifully delicious! Can’t wait to enjoy this salad, and so happy you get to enjoy them again too!

  16. Salad with nectarines?!Oh my! That’s yummy salad. I will try this one. Thanks

  17. oooooo……I so love this kind of dressing. I can’t wait to try your homemade recipe. my fav summer salad is a spinach strawberry so your chicken nectarine sounds delicious.

  18. Wonderful salad dressing. I was looking for a poppy seed dressing for a spinach salad – this was perfect. I halved the ingredients as there are just two of us but forgot to halve the mustard. I used grainy dijon and was very happy with my mistake. :)Thanks so much for posting – it will definitely be one of our standards!

  19. I’ve been looking for a recipe for poppyseed dressing! This one sounds amazing. I want to try to make it paleo by dropping the yogurt and using coconut sugar. Is there something I could use besides yogurt? Coconut milk I. Some form?

  20. Loved it! Just made it and it’s waiting in the fridge for dinner. For all those trying to reduce sugar consumption and move towards natural sugars, i found that adding 4 dried apricots in place of the refined sugar was enough to add a balance of sweetness (though probably not as much as refined sugar would add). Thanks for the recipe!

  21. Hi Lindsay!
    I’ve been stalking you for the last 6 weeks or so and am totally in love with your blog! The healthy portion is exactly what I’ve been needing for creating those nutritious yet tasty meals for my family. 2 questions about the dressing:
    cider vinegar seems hard to find…. is that similar to rice vinegar?
    olive oil mayonnaise – what would happen if I substituted regular mayonnaise or even miracle whip?

    • I’ve found cider vinegar at most grocery stores, but you could always just use white distilled vinegar as well. I think I would opt for regular mayo over Miracle Whip – it has such a distinct flavor and I’m not sure you’d want that.

      • Thanks! Turns out, my grocery store had just been out of cider vinegar for the last 6 months! Finally got some in though – gotta love the rural life :)

        • haha! too funny. reminds me of the Philippines! :)

          • just made this dressing again, except I added a cup of frozen raspberries to the mix. Ba-da-boom! Raspberry poppy seed dressing. Gorgeous and delicious. Bonus: my husband will actually eat salad for supper with this dressing (and chicken of course) :)

  22. Lindsay! I want to let you know that I made your homemade poppy seed dressing today. It’s incredible! Tastiest dressing I’ve had in a long, long time. Never buying it from the store again! Thanks for sharing this recipe – Kevin loved it too.

  23. Hi! This recipe looks awesome – I’m going to make it tonight because I feel like I spend half my paycheck on Brianna’s at the rate I go through it!

    One question though – how long would you say this will last in the fridge?

    Thanks so much!
    Love the blog!

  24. Wondering where the nutritional information is? I may have missed it. Thanks!

    • These are approximate because type of yogurt, mayo used will change if you use low-fat or full fat versions and whether you use wine or not (not included in this calculation).

      Per tablespoon; Calories 32.5 | Fat 2.57g | Carbs .95g |Protein 0.11g

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe: